About the Cake Cake History Cake filllings, icings, cake flavors Cake News & Events, New York, Long Island Our Customer Testimonials


“The mailbox cake for my husbands retirement was the hit of the party. Not only was it the most fantastic replica of a mailbox...it was absolutely delicious.

Because my husband is “so particular” the fruit combination was perfect. It was refreshing and delightful.

Thank you again for making my Terry’s day so special.”

Linda Wallack

“You made me a cake for my wedding last year. The cake was make to look like a Christmas gift - white with a red and gold ribbon on it. I want to first say that the cake was awesome - everyone loved it including myself and my husband.

We are coming up on our first anniversary and can not wait for the replica of our cake - yummy.

Hope your business is booming - I recommend you to everyone I know for anything they might need a cake for ! !

Thank you again for adding to the joy of our wedding day.”

Jennifer Kearney - Gappa

“Let me just tell you that his cakes are not only very elegant in appearance, but taste delicious.  Michael wasn't done any justice at the Great Bridal Show.  Let me just assure you that there is no question that he will be a perfect fit for your show at the Pierre Hotel.”

  Matt Victoria
Contemporary Bride Magazine

As Executive Chef / Owner of Butterfields Restaurant, I would like to take this opportunity to personally thank you for the outstanding desserts you provided. The recent rehearsal dinner for our customer, Mrs. Finkelstein on October 10, 2004 was a great success. Not only was the quality of the cakes exceptional, but all the “extras” you added gave Butterfields an extremely pleased customer. The complements were repeated over and over, from the cookie platters to the flowers on the cake. In my years as an Executive Chef, I have rarely been as pleased with a vendor as I am with the products and services at MaCayla Michaels Desserts. My expectations were more then exceeded in both the presentation and the flavor. Thank you again for a great job. I look forward to doing business with you again in the near future.

Jerry Suppa
Butterfields Restaurant

Just wanted to let you know this web site is beautiful. Your cakes are wonderful. I'll pass it along to anyone I know getting married or need a cake.

Deborah Shields

I was at the bridal expo at the Hilton in Melville.  I was able to sample your cake and it was like nothing I had ever had before.  I would love to set up an appointment to come and talk to somebody about the possibility of have you make my wedding cake. I hope to hear from you soon. once again I loved your cake.  

Jennifer Kearney

I stopped by your booth at the Great Bridal Expo in the Marriott Marquis.  If the sample you provided that evening is anything like what I'll receive on my wedding day, then an appointment is necessary. I look forward to hearing from you and meeting with you.  

Monique L. Gibbs

It was such a great privilege to meet both you and Michael last night. Thank you both for all of the help and making this planning such a joy. I am so lad you let me know you will be out east on the 21st. I will make it a point for both my fiance (Joe) and myself to be there so he can see exactly what I have been so excited over. I look forward to seeing you again.  

Andrea Cocco